Charter vs. share: when does buying pay off?
Reading time: about 12 minutes
Three weeks on a sailing boat in Croatia cost €9,000–10,500 a year, three weeks’ motorboat charter €24,000–30,000. On top of that, each time, come around €1,500 in additional costs that appear in hardly any charter catalogue. After three years you have spent around €31,500–36,000 on a sailing yacht, €75,000–95,000 on a motorboat, and you own: nothing.
For a quarter share in a Bavaria Cruiser 41 (sailing yacht, built 2015, Croatia) you pay a one-off approx. €25,000 plus approx. €3,125 running costs a year, in a Prestige 42 (motorboat) approx. €57,500 plus approx. €5,000. After around 3–3.5 years with the sailing yacht and 2–3 years with the motorboat, you are out on the water for less than with charter. From then on you save, every year.
This article works through both routes in full, with specific figures for motor and sail and with the additional costs that are often forgotten when chartering. It also says when charter remains the better choice. You can check it with your own figures in the calculator.
1. What charter really costs: the full calculation
At first glance, charter prices look manageable. At second glance, items appear that are in hardly any catalogue but that you pay on every booking.
Charter prices in high season (July/August, Croatia, bareboat)
| Boat type | Built approx. 2010 | Built 2020+ |
|---|---|---|
| Sailing boat (approx. 12 m) | €3,000–3,500/week | €3,500–5,000/week |
| Motorboat (approx. 13 m) | €8,000–10,000/week | €9,500–13,500/week |
Sources: europe-yachts.com, yacht-rent.de, boataround.com, kroatien-charter.com (as of 2025/2026). Newer models cost 20–40% more than older ones, so always state the year of build when comparing charters.
The additional costs hardly any catalogue mentions
On a typical 3-week booking in Croatia (motor or sail), these items come on top of the bare charter price:
| Item | Cost (approx.) | Frequency |
|---|---|---|
| Transit log / permit | €300–390 | 1× per booking |
| Outboard service (tender) | €350 | 1× per booking |
| Final cleaning | €285–300 | 1× per booking |
| Bed linen | €235 | 1× per booking |
| Charter excess insurance | €150–250 | 1× per booking |
| Parking (charter base) | €120 | 3 weeks × €40 |
| Total additional costs | approx. €1,450–1,650 | per booking |
Source: price list of a Croatian charter base, as of 2025/2026, and our own experience. Before fuel.
On your own boat (whole or as a share) these additional costs do not arise: the bed linen is in the locker, the tender hangs on the davits, you do the final clean yourself, and you need no parking space at the charter base, because your boat lies at your berth. In Croatia you pay the tourist tax and a vignette each year as an owner, both according to boat size; for a 50-foot boat together around €640 a year (based on experience, as of 2026).
Total charter costs per year
Three weeks in high season in Croatia, including all additional costs:
| Sailing boat (approx. 12 m, built 2015) | Motorboat (approx. 13 m, built 2010) | |
|---|---|---|
| Charter, 3 weeks | €9,000–10,500 | €24,000–30,000 |
| Additional costs | approx. €1,500 | approx. €1,500 |
| Total per year | €10,500–12,000 | €25,500–31,500 |
Charter prices from the first table, three weeks each; additional costs from the second table, rounded.
These are the figures you have to set against a boat share: not just the bare charter price, but everything together.
2. What a boat share costs: purchase price and running costs
A boat share costs you two things: the purchase price once, and the running costs every year. You split both according to your shares.
| Bavaria Cruiser 41 (sail, built 2015) | Prestige 42 (motor, built 2010) | |
|---|---|---|
| Market value, whole boat | approx. €100,000 | approx. €230,000 |
| ¼ share, purchase price | approx. €25,000 | approx. €57,500 |
| Total running costs / year | approx. €12,500 | approx. €19,500 |
| Your part of running costs / year | approx. €3,125 | approx. €5,000 |
| Use / year | 12 weeks on paper | 12 weeks on paper |
Running costs are based on the rule of thumb: boat length × €1,500/m/year (motorboat, Croatia) or €1,000/m/year (sailing boat, Croatia). Covers berth, insurance and routine maintenance. Excludes fuel and larger repairs.
Detailed breakdown of all cost items: What a boat really costs: the honest calculation
3. Break-even sail: Bavaria Cruiser 41, built 2015, Croatia
The decisive question: from what point has the share paid for itself compared with charter? This point is called break-even. Here is the calculation over 5 years, with 3 weeks’ charter a year in high season.
| Bavaria Cruiser 41, built 2015 | Charter (3 weeks/year) | ¼ share, ongoing | ¼ share with purchase price |
|---|---|---|---|
| Upfront costs | €0 | €0 | €25,000 |
| Year 1 | €10,500–12,000 | €3,125 | €28,125 |
| Year 2 | €21,000–24,000 | €6,250 | €31,250 |
| Year 3 | €31,500–36,000 | €9,375 | €34,375 |
| Year 4 | €42,000–48,000 | €12,500 | €37,500 |
| Year 5 | €52,500–60,000 | €15,625 | €40,625 |
| Use per year | 3 weeks | 12 weeks on paper | 12 weeks on paper |
| After 5 years | Nothing | Your share (residual value) | Your share (residual value) |
Figures from chapter 1 (charter with additional costs) and chapter 2 (purchase price and running costs of the share). The charter weeks are calculated at high-season prices. With a quarter, you are entitled to at least 2 weeks under our template in July and August; the rest of your 12 weeks on paper fall in the shoulder seasons.
Break-even: approx. 3–3.5 years.
With sailing boats it takes longer for the share to pay off, because the annual saving on charter is smaller (approx. €7,000–9,000/year instead of €20,000–26,000 with the motorboat). From year 4 you are ahead.
This table and the one in chapter 4 add up the costs year by year: “¼ share, ongoing” contains only your part of the running costs, “¼ share with purchase price” adds the one-off purchase price and is the column you compare with the charter column.
4. Break-even motor: Prestige 42, built 2010, Croatia
The calculation for motorboats looks different, because the charter prices are higher, but so are the running costs and the cost of the share.
| Prestige 42, built 2010 | Charter (3 weeks/year) | ¼ share, ongoing | ¼ share with purchase price |
|---|---|---|---|
| Upfront costs | €0 | €0 | €57,500 |
| Year 1 | €25,500–31,500 | €5,000 | €62,500 |
| Year 2 | €51,000–63,000 | €10,000 | €67,500 |
| Year 3 | €76,500–94,500 | €15,000 | €72,500 |
| Year 4 | €102,000–126,000 | €20,000 | €77,500 |
| Year 5 | €127,500–157,500 | €25,000 | €82,500 |
| Use per year | 3 weeks | 12 weeks on paper | 12 weeks on paper |
| After 5 years | Nothing | Your share (residual value) | Your share (residual value) |
Figures from chapter 1 (charter with additional costs) and chapter 2 (purchase price and running costs of the share). The charter weeks are calculated at high-season prices. With a quarter, you are entitled to at least 2 weeks under our template in July and August; the rest of your 12 weeks on paper fall in the shoulder seasons.
Break-even: approx. 2–3 years.
In the third year, the cumulative charter costs (including additional costs) exceed the sum of purchase price and running costs for the quarter share. From the third year you save approx. €20,000–26,000 a year with the share compared with charter.
5. The factor most people forget: residual value
After five years of charter you have nothing to show for it, only receipts.
After five years as a co-owner you have something in your hands: your share. You can sell it, leave it to your heirs or keep it. Yes, boats lose value. But with used boats beyond a certain age the curve flattens noticeably: a 15-year-old Bavaria Cruiser 41 in good condition loses less value per year than a 5-year-old one.
For the calculation this means: even if your share is worth only 75–85% of its purchase price after 5 years, you are left with something of value that you can turn into money. The condition is that a buyer pays you the value that corresponds to your part of the whole boat; sold on its own, a share often fetches less on the market. With the Bavaria Cruiser 41 that would be approx. €19,000–21,000 residual value for your quarter share, with the Prestige 42 €43,000–49,000.
If you include the residual value in the overall calculation, the break-even points shift even more clearly in favour of the share. With the Prestige 42 you are then already ahead after about a year, on the same condition.
6. When charter is still the better choice
A boat share is not the right decision for everyone. There are situations in which charter remains the better option:
You charter less than 2 weeks a year. If you charter only one week a year, you spend so little on it that a share only makes sense after many years, especially with sailing boats. Here charter is more flexible and makes more financial sense.
You want a different boat and a different cruising area every year. If it is the variety that appeals, Croatia this year, Sardinia next year, then the Caribbean, charter gives you a flexibility that owning a particular boat cannot offer.
You are not sure whether a boat is right for you at all. If you have never spent longer on a boat and are not sure life on board suits you, you should charter first, for two or three holidays. A boat share is a purchase of €21,250–57,500, and that should rest on real experience, not on an idea.
You really need the boat every weekend. If you use your boat 30 or 40 weeks a year, sole ownership is the right choice. With a quarter share you come to 12 weeks on paper; that is more than most people actually use, but too few for constant users.
The rule of thumb: if you regularly charter 3 or more weeks a year and can imagine using the same boat and cruising area for several years, a share pays off almost always. At less than 2 weeks a year it gets tight.
7. The hidden costs on both sides
A fair comparison also has to name the costs that are often overlooked with both options.
Hidden costs of charter
Additional costs: approx. €1,450–1,650 per booking (see above): transit log, final cleaning, bed linen, charter excess insurance, outboard, parking.
High-season availability: Popular boats in high season (July/August) are booked up early. If you book only in spring, you either pay considerably more or do not get the boat you wanted. As a co-owner you are entitled under our template to high-season weeks according to your share.
Quality lottery: With charter you never know exactly what condition the boat is in. Different crews, varying care, changing maintenance. On your own boat you know every scratch and you know what works and what does not.
Hidden costs of a share
Unplanned repairs: Engine, electronics, rig (on sailing boats). Repairs come, and they cost money. With a quarter you bear less of them, but not nothing. The Living Contract (co-owner agreement) provides for an annual reserve, so that such spending does not come as a surprise.
Time: A shared boat is work too. You coordinate with your co-owners, look after the boat and have a say in repairs. That is not a full-time job, but it is more than booking a charter. Some owners value exactly that, because then the boat feels like their boat, not like something hired.
Tied to one boat and cruising area: A share ties you to a specific boat in a specific place. If in two years you want a completely different boat, you first have to sell your share.
Purchase and brokerage: Incidental costs of buying come on top, such as a survey. When you buy through PartABoat, you pay the structuring fee and the seller a commission, both only if it comes to a purchase; the amounts are on How it works.
8. Do the sums yourself: the PartABoat calculator
The figures in this article are based on the PartABoat worked examples and rules of thumb. Your boat, your cruising area and your charter price may look different. In the PartABoat calculator you enter market value, boat length, boat type, cruising area, your charter price per week, your charter weeks per year and the size of the share.
The calculation applies in the same way if you buy as two or three: with a half or a third share you bear more of the purchase price and running costs, and your portion of the weeks of use on paper grows accordingly. What matters remains how many weeks a year you are really out on the boat.
The calculator shows you the upfront costs, the saving over 5 years and the break-even compared with charter, plus a table with the costs of both routes over 5 years. It includes the additional charter costs from chapter 1: around €1,500 for the one booking a year.
9. Frequently asked questions
Are the charter prices realistic?
The prices given apply to bareboat charter in high season (July/August) in Croatia. In the low season and in other cruising areas they can be considerably lower. If you charter only in the low season, you have a different break-even, which you can work out in the calculator with your own figures.
What if the value of the boat has fallen after 5 years?
Used boats lose value, especially in the first few years. From an age of 10–15 years the curve flattens. Even with 15–25% depreciation over 5 years there remains a residual value you can turn into money, provided that on selling you get your portion of the value of the whole boat; a single share often fetches less on the market. With charter, no residual value remains after 5 years.
Can I sell my share again?
Yes. Your share is real ownership: you can sell it on the PartABoat marketplace or privately; the other co-owners can reject your buyer only for good cause relating to that person, and only within 30 calendar days of your notice. Among themselves they have a right to buy and can take over your share at the price your buyer would pay. There is no minimum period of ownership before you can sell.
How many weeks do I get with a quarter share?
12 weeks a year on paper; you decide together in the Living Contract how to allocate the weeks. The PartABoat template allocates the high season by share; if you set July and August as the high season, each owner is entitled to at least 2 weeks under our template. Actual use depends on your circumstances; 12 weeks are a calculation, not a guarantee of use.
What if I want to charter more later, in another cruising area?
A share does not rule out charter. You can use your boat as your base and also charter in other cruising areas when you want to try something new. The share lowers your basic costs for regular use, and charter remains an option for occasional variety.
Does the comparison also work for German inland waters?
In principle yes, but charter prices on inland waters (Rhine, Mecklenburg, Lake Constance) are considerably lower than in Croatia. At the same time, running costs are lower too (€800–1,000/m/year motor, €600/m/year sail). The break-even shifts, but the basic logic remains: if you are out regularly, ownership works out cheaper.
Conclusion
With a sailing yacht, 5 years set €52,500–60,000 of charter against approx. €40,625 for a quarter; after 3–3.5 years you have spent less and you keep the residual value.
The calculation is clear: if you regularly charter a motorboat for 3 weeks a year, you spend €127,500–157,500 in 5 years and own nothing at the end. A quarter share in a comparable motorboat costs approx. €82,500 over 5 years, and afterwards you have something of value in your hands.
That does not mean chartering is bad. It means chartering becomes considerably more expensive once you go often enough. And that co-ownership (fractional ownership) is not an exotic idea but a sensible decision for anyone who does the sums themselves.
Do the sums yourself: calculator View all boats Boat chat All guides
About the author: Ekki is the founder of PartABoat and a co-owner of two motorboats, one in Croatia, the other on the Rhine. He chartered for years before he bought his first boat. The charter prices in this article come from current market data. For motorboats the running costs use rules of thumb from his own experience, for sailing boats guide values from market research.